Physical Education is supposed to help young people develop physically, socially and personally. Yet for many transgender students, it can become one of the places where school feels least safe. New evidence from the University of Valencia, Spain, shows that trans students experience substantially more harassment, exclusion and avoidance in Physical Education than cisgender students. The differences are especially marked among non-binary students.
They show how apparently ordinary school routines such as changing clothes, choosing teams, demonstrating an exercise, or joining an excursion can become barriers when they are organised around rigid assumptions about gender.
A subject built around the body
Physical education is different from most classroom subjects because students’ bodies are constantly visible. They perform, compete, change clothes and are often assessed in front of their peers. Activities, facilities and teams are also frequently organised around a male/female binary.
For transgender students, these structures can turn everyday participation into a negotiation over identity. Previous research has documented how changing rooms, bathrooms, gendered activities and sporting expectations can create particularly difficult experiences for trans and gender-diverse students.
The Spanish study examined 393 adults who identified as either transgender or cisgender and looked back at their experiences during schooling. The sample included trans men, trans women, non-binary participants, cis women and cis men. Although the study captures retrospective rather than current pupils’ experiences, it provides a rare quantitative comparison between the two groups.
Harassment is not evenly distributed
Around one-third of participants (32.5%) reported experiencing harassment in educational settings. But the differences between groups were striking. Educational harassment was reported by 64.9% of trans non-binary participants, 60.6% of trans women and 48.3% of trans men, compared with 8.2% of cis women and 4.4% of cis men.
The pattern extended across different forms of harassment. Verbal harassment was reported by 56.8% of trans non-binary participants and 48.5% of trans women, compared with 6.8% of cis women and 4.4% of cis men. Physical harassment affected 32.4% of trans non-binary participants and 27.3% of trans women, while none of the cis participants in the study reported it. These findings are consistent with wider evidence of elevated victimisation among trans young people.
The non-binary group experienced the highest levels of several forms of harassment. This is important because treating “LGBT students” as one homogeneous group can hide substantial differences. Gender identity and sexual orientation do not necessarily produce the same experience of school or Physical Education.
Changing rooms become a test of belonging
Few spaces illustrate the problem more clearly than changing rooms. More than half of trans participants (53.4%) reported that they almost always or always changed in a locker room that did not correspond with their gender identity. Among trans men, the figure reached 62.7%. For cis participants, it was only 4%.
Trans students were also much less likely to shower or undress in front of classmates. Only 22.1% of trans participants said they almost always or always undressed in front of classmates, compared with 63.7% of cis participants.
These are not simply questions of comfort. Changing rooms can determine whether students participate fully in Physical Education, whether they feel able to remain in school spaces and whether they can avoid unwanted exposure or harassment. Research on trans and non-binary students has repeatedly identified facilities and changing spaces as significant barriers to participation.
This piece explores how transgender students experience exclusion in school physical education classes.
— Javier Gil Quintana
Avoidance can look like disengagement
One of the study’s most revealing findings is how often trans students avoided Physical Education.
Compared with cis students, trans participants were more likely to pretend to be injured, forget their sports clothing or equipment, skip lessons and leave sessions unfinished. They were also less likely to participate in Physical Education excursions and extracurricular activities. Nearly 10% of trans participants reported failing Physical Education always or almost always, compared with less than 1% of cis participants.
These behaviours could easily be interpreted as a lack of motivation. The findings suggest another possibility: avoidance can be a response to an environment perceived as hostile or unsafe. Previous research has similarly documented withdrawal from Physical Education and sport among trans students as a strategy for avoiding discrimination.
This distinction matters for teachers. If a student repeatedly misses Physical Education, the first question should not necessarily be “Why won’t they participate?” It may be more useful to ask what makes participation difficult.
Teachers shape the climate
The study also found differences in the relationship between students and Physical Education teachers. Trans participants were selected less often to demonstrate activities and were more frequently the last students chosen when teams were formed.
For example, 45.8% of trans men and 40.5% of trans non-binary participants said they were never selected by their Physical Education teacher to demonstrate an exercise. By contrast, the figure was 10.3% among cis women and 12.8% among cis men. Similar differences appeared in team selection.
The research does not establish why teachers behaved differently. The authors suggest several possible explanations, including uncertainty about how to respond to gender diversity, avoidance of difficult conversations or the reproduction of binary assumptions. What the evidence does show is that teacher practice is part of the environment students experience.
As the literature on LGBTQ+ experiences in Physical Education argues, inclusion requires more than good intentions. Teachers need practical ways to recognise diversity and create environments in which students can participate without having to defend their identity.
What should change?
Schools can examine whether changing rooms and bathrooms offer alternatives to rigid binary arrangements. Physical Education teachers can review how they form teams, assign activities and select students for demonstrations. Inclusive language and clear responses to verbal aggression can also reduce the burden placed on individual students to protect themselves.
Teacher education is equally important. The authors argue that educational professionals, particularly Physical Education teachers, need training on gender identity and the ways cisnormative structures can shape everyday practice.
The aim is not to create a special version of Physical Education for trans students. It is to question routines that make participation easier for some students and harder for others. Research on trans-inclusive Physical Education similarly points towards changing the structures and assumptions of the subject, rather than asking marginalised students simply to adapt to them.
One sentence from the study captures the practical challenge particularly clearly: Physical Education must stop failing trans students.
That means thinking about success differently. A Physical Education lesson is not fully inclusive if every student is technically allowed to attend but some must avoid changing rooms, hide their identity, endure insults or deliberately miss the lesson to feel safe.
Reference
Gil-Quintana, J., Valencia-Peris, A., López-Cañada, E., Serra, P., & Lisahunter. (2026). Normativity and oppression: cis and trans students’ experiences in physical education. Sport, Education and Society, 1-16. https://doi.org/10.1080/13573322.2026.2697323
